Hybridisation of digital and physical space is now a reality for geographies of sexualities in the digital age. ‘This chapter builds on such an understanding by exploring how digital–physical hybridisation mediated by locative dating apps can shape queer male ‘practice-based’ identities, and how these typologies in turn inform physical queer encounters. Drawing from a qualitative research project with men who have sex with men (MSM), I examine the impact of online connection on different ‘routes’ to physical meeting. I argue that certain modes of behaviour help to identify a range of practice-based identities, implicitly linked to different forms of hybridisation. Three typologies exemplify practice-based identities: the ‘Embracer’, the ‘Time-waster’ and the ‘Minimalist’. These fluid typologies overlap and are even evident within a single identity across time, depending on personal motivation, the ‘market’ of available online matches, and app genre. Such typologies demonstrate the range of user engagement that becomes bound up in, and mediated by, the digital and physical hybridisation enabled by popular mobile media platforms. The development of practice-based identities can be extrapolated beyond thinking about online and offline spaces to new questions about future sexualities, identities and digital geographies.