Meta-analysis, complexity, and heterogeneity: a qualitative interview study of researchers' methodological values and practices.

Theo Lorenc ORCID logo ; Lambert Felix ORCID logo ; Mark Petticrew ORCID logo ; GJ Melendez-Torres ; James Thomas ; Sian Thomas ; Alison O'Mara-Eves ; Michelle Richardson ; (2016) Meta-analysis, complexity, and heterogeneity: a qualitative interview study of researchers' methodological values and practices. Systematic reviews, 5 (1). 192-. ISSN 2046-4053 DOI: 10.1186/s13643-016-0366-6
Copy

BACKGROUND: Complex or heterogeneous data pose challenges for systematic review and meta-analysis. In recent years, a number of new methods have been developed to meet these challenges. This qualitative interview study aimed to understand researchers' understanding of complexity and heterogeneity and the factors which may influence the choices researchers make in synthesising complex data. METHODS: We conducted interviews with a purposive sample of researchers (N = 19) working in systematic review or meta-analysis across a range of disciplines. We analysed data thematically using a framework approach. RESULTS: Participants reported using a broader range of methods and data types in complex reviews than in traditional reviews. A range of techniques are used to explore heterogeneity, but there is some debate about their validity, particularly when applied post hoc. CONCLUSIONS: Technical considerations of how to synthesise complex evidence cannot be isolated from questions of the goals and contexts of research. However, decisions about how to analyse data appear to be made in a largely informal way, drawing on tacit expertise, and their relation to these broader questions remains unclear.


picture_as_pdf
Meta-analysis complexity and heterogeneity_GOLD VoR.pdf
subject
Published Version
Available under Creative Commons: Attribution 3.0

View Download

Atom BibTeX OpenURL ContextObject in Span Multiline CSV OpenURL ContextObject Dublin Core Dublin Core MPEG-21 DIDL Data Cite XML EndNote HTML Citation JSON MARC (ASCII) MARC (ISO 2709) METS MODS RDF+N3 RDF+N-Triples RDF+XML RIOXX2 XML Reference Manager Refer Simple Metadata ASCII Citation EP3 XML
Export

Downloads